ENHANCING LAYOUT PHOTOGRAPHS
Peter Smith
My friend John Smith's layout, Sellindge, is at the stage now where visually it is pretty much complete, although no doubt small improvements will continue to be made. We have recently done three shows with the layout, which gave us the chance to take a lot of pictures, as the only time the layout is put up in one piece is at exhibitions. The layout represents a Southern Railway main line in Kent in 1947. Sellindge is a real place but it never had a station, though in our reality it is the junction for a branch running to Lympne.

John and I have both recently bought digital cameras, and have been finding out what they can do. I find them easy to use and ideal for photographing the layout, but one problem cannot be easily overcome, and that is the unrealistic background of the exhibition hall intruding into the pictures. If you just want a record of the event, that is fine, but I like to try and capture a scene that looks as realistic as possible, particularly from low level to give the viewpoint of a figure standing on the layout. The roof of the hall is invariably present in the pictures.



Above - a worst case scenario. This has just about everything you don't want in the background.

Below - the improved picture. There is a lot of work in this clean up. Note the distant scenery below the sky - on both sides of the church; and that the train has disappeared!


 


Walls and screens behind the layout, not particularly distractive in this case but open to improvement.

 

Once again there is a distant landscape below the sky.
Important to give that natural appearance to the overall landscape.

 

I decided to see if I could get around this by loading the images on to the computer and altering the background, cutting out the unrealistic part and replacing it with something else. The four pictures included here show 'before and after' examples. I have chosen four views without trains, as I wanted to see if there was enough interest in the pictures without a train being present. It is also a very good way of assessing how well a scene has been modelled, as the camera picks up imperfections that you don't notice while looking at the layout itself.

I took the pictures here by standing the camera on the layout, either on the track or another surface; this eliminates any shake which could spoil the image, and gives a realistic viewpoint. I was using an Olympus compact camera, which is small enough to take views that cannot normally be seen, as you could not physically get your head to that point. For more distant shots, a tripod is recommended. No lighting was used other than the daylight bulbs in the layout lights and the natural background. I turned off the flash on the camera, hence the longer time taken to record the image and the need to steady the camera.

The four images chosen here illustrate well the problems you face, and show how to get around them quite simply. I have a series of photographs stored on my computer that are simply landscapes, taken at different times of year and with different skies, but without much foreground detail. These are used to replace the unwanted part of the model photograph.

The software I use is quite old now, Livepix, which was designed originally for Windows 95. I am familiar with it, and it does all I need, although more modern programs such as Adobe Photoshop are more flexible.

Looking first at the photograph of the church seen across the river, the picture is spoilt by the very messy background, and the foreground is out of focus. The buildings are hardly noticeable against the roof and the people looking at the layout. The first job, then, is to remove the unwanted area by using the 'cutting' tool on the computer screen, tracing round the area to be removed until it is surrounded, and then clicking the mouse. Magically, the unwanted part vanishes, and the part of the image to be kept remains against a white screen. It is a bit complicated cutting around chimneys and so forth, but enlarging the image helps.

The next job is to choose an appropriate sky / countryside background, and insert it into the picture so that it lies behind the model image. It can be moved around until it lines up, and several can be tried until the best is found. I wanted a fairly neutral image here as the model was the important thing. When the background was in place, I next blurred the edge of the cut-out model picture as a stark line looked wrong; slight blurring makes the two images blend together and appear as one. It is possible to increase the brightness, or alter the colour balance, but I was happy with the picture as it stood. I added a simple green frame and that was that.

Some may argue that this is cheating, and that a picture should be left alone, but I am not trying to pretend that this is an image of the layout as it really is. I just wanted to make a photo of the model look as realistic as possible for my own pleasure. To me, it certainly gives a feeling of distance, far more so than in the original picture.

The second picture shows a view in the other direction, looking under the footbridge with the signalbox on the left. Again, the original has a blurred foreground and although the background is less intrusive it is not realistic. I wanted to alter this, but it was complicated by the fact that part of the background is viewed through the footbridge, and another section is behind the box. Three separate cut-out operations had to be done before dropping in a suitably bland sky that would not draw attention from the models. In this case it was difficult to blur the model image because of the signalbox and the bridge, so this was not done. With man-made objects for the join between the two images, a sharp line looks okay.

 
Next, I took a shot of an oasthouse seen between some trees. The original shot was quite pleasing, but the top of the layout backscene made a line running across the 'sky' which I wanted to remove. I also cut off the out-of-focus foreground of the picture. Because the sky is seen through the trees, little sections had to be cut out here as well before the background was inserted and the model image blurred slightly at the edges. Little work was needed to make an adequate picture look much more convincing, yet the image of the models has not been altered at all.

 

The edge of the bocking board could be removed very easily by simply extending the white surface to the top of the picture but, once again, the small infill of distant scenery and a bit of colour in the sky improves the overall realisim.

 

The fourth photo was taken from a viewpoint that would be impossible for a human being, or indeed a larger camera, looking along the approach road behind the station building. The original image is a 'nothing shot', with too much grey road, a messy background, and what is clearly a low relief building on the left.

 

To alter the image, I cut out a lot of the foreground, removed the lefthand edge to make the garage look convincing, and removed the background too. Again, I wanted a fairly bland background to focus the attention on the bus, so a cloudy sky was chosen here before the image was finished with a simple frame.

I ended up with four pictures that look to me real scenes, yet the only alteration was to remove unwanted areas, the image of the models themselves has not been altered in any way. What you see is a picture of the models as they really are on Sellindge, as anyone that has seen the layout at an exhibition will testify.

 
Finally, I thought you might be interested to see how one of the scenes looks with different backgrounds inserted behind it; nothing else has been changed, but it is surprising how different the picture can be made to look.

The four pictures show 'variations'; right - the basic cut out removing the unwanted background. Below left - a simple sky added (from the centre 'background' picture (below) - the church is hidden behind the buildings); then a bit of distant scenery added, this time from the left hand picture below; and right, a different 'scenery' where the right hand picture below has been reversed to put the windmill in the correct position. The end of the red roof of the house and the adjoining building can also be seen.

 

The next stage on from this is to add items such as smoke to model trains,
which can be incredibly effective, but is perhaps a little more contentious.
A later article might look at this.



These are three 'background' pictures which provide sky and distant scenery.